Drywall Anchors: Some are better than others

Just about every room has something anchored to drywall. But you don’t always have the luxury of a stud where you need it. So you (and I) turn to drywall anchors. They are packaged with everything from picture frames to towel bars. But some are better than others.

Expansion Drywall Anchors

Expansion anchors are the most common. A typical installation goes something like this. First, you drill a hole and press the anchor inside. Then screw into the anchor. Seems simple enough. Be sure to drill the right size hole for you anchor. Don’t force them as they will break (just like my picture). Expansion anchors can’t hold much weight. Only use them for hanging light objects. One good way to remove them is put in a screw part way. Pull on the screw to remove.


Threaded Drywall Anchor

Threaded anchors are available in nylon and metal. Metal anchors won’t break as easily but nylons have never failed me. They are self starting so you won’t have to bother pre-drilling. Simply screw them into your drywall till flush. Threaded anchors can also hold more weight, approximately 15 - 20 pounds. These anchors have a larger “face” so be sure the item your hanging will hide it.

These aren’t the only wall anchors available but should be enough to tackle most hanging projects. Be sure the anchor can hold the weight and the weight is directed downward (not leaning outward).

What do you think? What anchors do you use?

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
March 27th, 2008 | Posted by: Ethan
Categories: Materials | Trackback

5 Responses to “Drywall Anchors: Some are better than others”

  1. I’ve always used the plastic kind that you use with screws. I’ve never tried the self-tapping kind you describe here. I guess one downside would be if you ever move what you’ve hung, the threaded anchor’s hole would be bigger to patch.

  2. I’ve never (EVER!) had success with the expansion anchors. They only serve to tick me off.

    Believe it or not, but I’ve had a lot of success with “Hercules Hooks.” I saw them on a silly infomercial and later picked them up at a “As Seen On TV” store. They worked real well and were easy enough for my Beloved Bride to setup herself.

    -Jon

  3. Jon,

    I completely agree. Expansion anchors are really frustrating. Too bad every manufacturer distributes them. I’ve never tried the “Hercules Hook”. Thanks for the tip

  4. I didn’t know about the threaded ones. Never had much luck with expansion anchors, so I will be sure to try these next time, and will also investigate the Hercules hooks recommended by Jon

  5. I’ll second the hercules hooks… we’ve used them for most of our pictures. They work great! Tiny little hole, too.

    I’ve had OK luck with the expansion type anchors…

Leave a Reply